Federal vs. State Life Insurance Claims

Jason Turchin, Esq. Team

When dealing with life insurance claims, understanding the distinction between federal and state jurisdictions is often crucial. This knowledge not may only help in formulating a legal strategy but also in anticipating potential challenges that may arise during the claims process.

Federal Life Insurance Claims

Federal claims generally involve life insurance policies that are governed by federal law, such as those provided by employers or as part of group benefits. The most common type of federal claims involves policies under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA).

Key Characteristics:

  • Preemption: ERISA generally preempts state laws, which means that state insurance regulations and consumer protection laws may not apply.
  • Appeal Process: The appeal process for denied claims under federal jurisdiction is more stringent. Claimants typically must exhaust all administrative remedies before pursuing litigation.
  • Limited Remedies: Remedies under ERISA are often limited to the amount of the policy benefit. Punitive damages and state-law penalties are generally not recoverable.

State Life Insurance Claims

State claims adhere to the laws and regulations set forth by the state where the policy was issued or where the policyholder resides. These laws typically cover most individually purchased life insurance policies and regulate the terms of the insurance contract, claims handling practices, and other aspects of the policy.

Key Characteristics:

  • Consumer Protections: State laws often provide broader consumer protection against unfair claims handling practices.
  • Flexibility in Remedies: In addition to recovering policy benefits, claimants may be able to seek punitive damages or other penalties if the insurer acted in bad faith.
  • Regulatory Oversight: State insurance departments actively regulate and monitor life insurance companies, potentially providing an additional layer of protection for policyholders.

ERISA Life Insurance Claims

The Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) governs most life insurance policies issued in connection with employment. Understanding ERISA’s impact on life insurance claims is generally important for beneficiaries facing a denied claim.

Challenges of ERISA Claims:

  • Strict Deadlines: ERISA often imposes strict deadlines for filing claims and appeals, which can be a trap for the unwary.
  • Limited Judicial Review: Courts generally have limited ability to review ERISA plan decisions. Unless the plan’s decision was arbitrary and capricious, it may be upheld.
  • Complex Procedures: Navigating ERISA’s procedural rules often requires specific knowledge and experience.

Strategies for Success:

  • Detailed Documentation: Keeping meticulous records of all communications with the insurer and all documents submitted during the claim process can be vital.
  • Legal Representation: Given the complexities and limitations of ERISA, professional legal representation is often essential to navigate the claims process successfully.

OFEGLI Life Insurance Claims

The Office of Federal Employees’ Group Life Insurance (OFEGLI) administers life insurance for federal employees under the Federal Employees’ Group Life Insurance (FEGLI) program. Claiming benefits under FEGLI can differ significantly from other types of life insurance claims.

Key Points:

  • Coverage Scope: FEGLI provides group term life insurance for federal employees and offers basic life coverage along with three types of additional insurance.
  • Claim Filing Process: Beneficiaries must generally submit a completed claim form along with a certified copy of the death certificate. The process is straightforward but must be followed precisely to avoid delays.
  • Dispute Resolution: Disputes over FEGLI benefits may involve unique challenges, such as issues related to eligibility or beneficiary designation disputes.

Can you win a denied life insurance claim?

Yes, sometimes you can. Life insurance companies often make mistakes and wrongfully deny otherwise valid claims. Navigating the complexities of life insurance claims, whether under federal, state, or specific programs like ERISA or OFEGLI, often requires a comprehensive understanding of the relevant laws and regulations. At the Law Offices of Jason Turchin, our experience is wide in life insurance law, helping to ensure that beneficiaries receive knowledgeable guidance and effective representation. If you are facing challenges with a life insurance claim, contact us to explore how we can assist you in securing your benefits and upholding your rights.

Client Reviews

"I am very grateful to have found Jason Turchin! Mr Turchin did not hesitate to accept my case when there was no other attorney willing to accept me. Every decision that Mr Turchin proceeded with was made with professionalism along with knowledge, therefore doing what was in my best interest. Also...

V. S.

"My experience with Jason Turchin and staff was delightful. They made a bad experience a good one. I valued their representation and opinion. I trusted them and would do it again in a heart beat! I recommend them to anyone and everyone!"


Very Satisfied Across The Board! I would definitely recommend Jason Turchin and his firm. Francine was so helpful and a pleasure to work with! I don't know where I would be regarding all of this if it wasn't for her! Jason Turchin was easy to reach, and I was very satisfied with the office in...


Get in Touch

  1. 1 Free Consultation
  2. 2 Available 24/7
  3. 3 Serving Florida, NJ, NY, and Washington, DC.
Fill out the contact form or call us at (954) 515-5000 to schedule your free consultation.

Leave Us a Message